Thursday, June 18, 2009

Is More Less?

Birth Control is a touchy subject around the world, but not so much in India. Although public discussion is absent but there is no real opposition to it either. If we were to take up the argument of population as a bane, then contraception would be an effective arsenal at our disposal. Especially considering the more disturbing alternative to get the same result: Abortion.

But if we look at population as an asset regardless of the economic and social implications then the morality of population control comes apart. The Roman Catholic faith is a vocal proponent of this opinion and their justifications are derived from the scriptures, although other Christian sects might not agree. Islam too is a not very keen on the idea of contraception and this is plain to see through the prevalent fertility rate in most Islamic communities. But Hinduism is a major religion which does not prescribe to any particular view on the subject. The lack of a moral compass from the Hindu faith on the subject has driven India's policy on population control into the hands of economists and scientists.

Therefore from the time of abortion being made legal in 1971 in India it took just a few years for the unpopular sterilization program under the Government's Family Planning initiative to get operationalized. Although the actual program was shelved due to its implementation, but the idea that population is India's burden has persisted. Today birth control is a common practice, couples are encouraged to use contraceptives, some local body elections do not allow candidates with too many children. The popularity of contragestion apart from contraception is a testimony to growing perception that population control is necessary.

The one-child policy adopted by China as a method of policy implementation is debated widely. But successive governments in India have tried to achieve similar results without creating a law. Therefore the mission of birth control was sought to be achieved through engineering consent among the public. Hence a generation was taught that excess population is a liability. And this effort has worked, although not to the levels of the Chinese extremes but to the extend that was possible without twisting arms.

Today there is practically no debate on birth control, none of the manifestos in the recent election had anything of note in this direction. The deficit of voices on this crucial issue is a matter of grave concern since birth control defines the structure of future societies and it has the power to fundamentally alter the institution of family.

A great telugu poet Gurazada Apparao once said : "Desamante matti kaadoyi, desamante manushuloyi" meaning, A country is not made of land; a country is made of its people.


Thursday, June 4, 2009

The Spoken Word

It is hard enough to convince one other person but to do so with millions of people takes some outrageous oratory skills. There is no denying that persuasion is only partly accomplished with words but without the right words it gets exponentially harder. The religions of old are a product of some profound arguments and the most effective manner of delivering these argument is rhetoric. Ideological demigods always knew oral propaganda to be the most potent tool at their disposal. And today we see a shining example of what the spoken word can accomplish in Mr. Barack Obama.

The understanding of language and the ways in which it moves people is complex and goes beyond the mere use of apt syntax or appropriate semantics. A compelling argument will do to people what a magnet does to nails: attract and align. Today Mr. Obama gave yet another rousing speech titled "On a New Beginning" at Cairo University addressed to the Muslims of the world. Someone shouted out "We love you" and no one was reaching for their shoe, a marked improvement for the office of President of United States in the space of six months. A change in voice can do that, obviously the message was different from the Bush doctrine but also the way it was delivered must hold some bearing. Here was the most profound manifestation of what one man's words can do in shaping the image of a nation in the eyes of a people.

Mr. Obama has been doing this for sometime now, from the Democratic National Convention of '04 and "A More Perfect Union" speech from his own campaign to the "Yes We Can" victory address and "A World without Nuclear Weapons" speech in Prague. Even the Tricky Abortion debate at Notre Dame was handled with sensitivity and understanding. Some of this leading to a Daily Show comedy sketch comparing Obama to Superman! Mr. Obama too has mockingly compared himself to Jesus for all the fans of his sermons.


Every country has been on the hunt for its own Obama since his rise but what the public means by this is not the just the politics and symbolism of Mr. Obama but also the appeal that such oratory kindles in them. Indian media too was awash with the search of the Indian Obama and leaders in all parts of the country have cited the American leader as an inspiration and cast themselves as his Indian avatar during the recent elections. But persuasion is a talent that is elusive to most. In Andhra Pradesh, India a popular movie actor, Mr. Chiranjeevi tried his hand at using a similar message of change in his campaign for the state election, but his speeches were a disappointment and his campaign derailed.


(In Picture: Praja Rajyam Party's Chiranjeevi projected as a Mr. Obama's counterpart in Andhra Pradesh, India)

Yet all is not lost for the Indian politician, I'll conclude this piece therefore with an example of a combative speech given in the thick of the Trust Vote debate in the Indian Parliament by Mr. Omar Abdullah on July 22nd 2008. This one speech helped many conclude that what transpired on that shameful day was atleast not a complete farce.


Monday, June 1, 2009

Crime Capital

Stuartpuram is a town in Andhra Pradesh, India which is famous or rather infamous for one particular export. Much like with the IT prowess of India exported to the rest of the world, this Stuartpuram export too is a skill. People in the know can disregard this drum roll, but for the rest - the talent is crime. There is a proud tradition of burglary, extortion and other forms of foul play at Stuartpuram. Yet this identity is not geographical but a communal identity of a tribe.

Theft and deception is said to be this community's occupation. In fact this tribe was covered in the draconian sounding "Criminal Tribes Act of 1871" framed by the British which basically supposed that there is a gene for criminal behavior. They were convinced of the "Born Criminal" doctrine and that Nature ultimately holds sway over Nurture. For good measure there is even a telugu movie by the name "Stuartpuram Police Station" starring the reigning star of the times in '91 - Chiranjeevi to further the legend.



Movie Poster : Stuartpuram Police Station

From accounts, Stuartpuram was a town that was used by the British to resettle the "Criminal Tribe" since the tribe was itself nomadic as it had to be when the stated occupation is such. To be fair though, the tribe's traditional vocation is said to be hunting for game, but they had to adapt once they were ejected from their forest habitats. The Act itself was repelled at the time of Independence but the stigma must surely remain. The town is still considered as the heart and brains of crimes both petty and extraordinary in the state. And so for all purposes this town is at the top of law enforcement's list whenever there is heist of note.

It is hard to escape one's extraction but easier to embrace cliches. Yet there have been reformers trying their hand at "rehabilitating" the citizens of the town. But the "Kula-Vruthi"- a word that means profession but in an almost karmatic manner, of these people is unfortunately not just reaffirmed by the larger society but also by the community itself on many occasion. People come from everywhere to Stuartpuram when the service of larceny is required. For the police the town is a one-stop shop for concluding their theft cases.

The irony here is that although there is scant respect for the law among the deviant elements of Stuartpuram yet these are the very people who best understand the law for what it is and its limitations in life. While rest of India lives a self contained existence which dare not test the boundaries of the norm, here are a bunch of intrepid citizens who see the country now as the British once saw it - Jungle Raj.

Interesting Readings:
  1. http://www.hindu.com/2008/03/20/stories/2008032058440300.htm
  2. http://ccnmtl.columbia.edu/projects/mmt/ambedkar/web/readings/Simhadri.pdf
  3. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yerukala